
The Gallivant Times Square
Best for families and theatergoers who want to be steps from Times Square and Broadway.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Gallivant Times Square is a 334-room, family-friendly boutique hotel in Midtown’s Theater District with on-site dining and a 24-hour fitness center—good for travelers who want immediate access to Broadway and Times Square. The New York EDITION is a 5-star luxury lifestyle hotel by Madison Square Park, aimed at design-minded travelers who prefer Flatiron/Gramercy access and a high-end restaurant-and-bar program.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for families and theatergoers who want to be steps from Times Square and Broadway.

Best for design-focused travelers who want a luxury lifestyle hotel near Madison Square Park and Flatiron.
When The Gallivant Times Square wins: Choose The Gallivant if you want a more budget-conscious Midtown base with family-friendly room types (including bunk-style family rooms), easy walking access to Broadway theaters and Times Square, and on-site casual dining.
When The New York EDITION wins: Pick The New York EDITION for a luxury stay in the Flatiron/Madison Square Park area, a higher-end restaurant and multiple bars, and a polished lifestyle-hotel service level with meeting space for small events.
Bottom line: For a central, family-oriented Midtown location with straightforward amenities and lower price positioning, The Gallivant is the practical choice; for a luxury, design-forward stay near Madison Square Park with signature dining and lounge options, the EDITION is the better fit.
| Category | The Gallivant Times Square | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, practical Midtown hotel focused on families and theater guests | Luxury lifestyle hotel with contemporary design and higher service level |
| Location | 234 West 48th Street — steps from Times Square and Broadway theaters (Theater District/Midtown West) | 5 Madison Avenue — steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building |
| Size (rooms) | 334 guest rooms | 271 air-conditioned rooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; check-in guest must be 18+ | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | An'nam (Vietnamese/Japanese), Ding (tabletop Korean BBQ), lobby cocktail bar | The Clocktower (restaurant), 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; refreshed 24-hour fitness center | On-site spa services and 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Proximity to Broadway and Times Square; family rooms and bunk-bed options | Marriott EDITION brand design, Madison Square Park/Flatiron location, signature dining |
| Meeting & event space | Four event/meeting spaces (Boardroom, Lobby, An'Nam, Ding) including an 80-person banquet room | Conference space ~2,100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
| Wi‑Fi & fees | Complimentary Wi‑Fi; mandatory facility fee ($40 + tax per night) covers Wi‑Fi and gym | Complimentary wired and wireless internet; mandatory destination fee (~USD 51.64/night) |
The Gallivant puts you in Midtown West within easy walking distance of Times Square and Broadway.
Choose The Gallivant for immediate access to Broadway and Midtown attractions.
The New York EDITION sits by Madison Square Park in the Flatiron/Gramercy edge of Manhattan.
Choose the EDITION for Flatiron/Madison Square Park access and a different neighborhood feel from Times Square.
The Gallivant offers many room configurations, including family-focused layouts and some balcony rooms.
The Gallivant is practical for families who need flexible bedding and extra beds aren’t offered.
The New York EDITION provides a range of luxury room types and suites.
The EDITION is aimed at guests who want luxury room finishes and a variety of suite options.
The Gallivant’s on-site dining covers family-style and interactive options.
The Gallivant works well for convenient, family-friendly meals before or after theater shows.
The New York EDITION emphasizes a signature restaurant and multiple lounge options.
The EDITION is better suited to travelers seeking a higher-end in-hotel dining and bar program.
The Gallivant does not list an on-site swimming pool.
Expect no pool but a 24-hour gym for workouts.
The New York EDITION highlights spa services and full fitness facilities.
The EDITION provides on-site wellness services and round-the-clock fitness access.
The Gallivant focuses on practical guest services and nearby options for wellness.
Good practical services for city stays and family travel; spa treatments require leaving the property.
The EDITION emphasizes concierge, bars, and in-house spa treatments.
Expect full-service luxury conveniences — at additional per-stay or per-service cost.

The Gallivant — steps from Broadway theaters and Times Square; ideal for evening shows and Midtown sightseeing.

The New York EDITION — signature restaurant (The Clocktower) plus two bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.

The Gallivant — family rooms and bunk-friendly layouts; children welcome and many family-oriented room options.

The New York EDITION — Marriott EDITION branding, design focus, and multiple suite and accessible room types.
The Gallivant Times Square — it’s in the Theater District and a short walk to many Broadway houses.
The New York EDITION lists on-site spa services; The Gallivant does not have an on-site spa. Neither property reliably lists an on-site swimming pool.
The Gallivant is the better family choice — it offers family rooms and bunk-bed layouts and explicitly welcomes children of all ages.
Yes. The Gallivant charges a mandatory facility fee (about $40 + tax per night). The New York EDITION charges a destination fee (listed at about USD 51.64 per night) and may add surcharges for valet parking, breakfast, and pet stays.
Explore how The Gallivant Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·