
The Gallivant Times Square
Best for theatergoers and families who want a convenient, walkable base steps from Times Square and Broadway.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Gallivant Times Square is a midpriced, family-friendly boutique hotel in the Theater District with 334 flexible rooms and on-site dining—good for travelers who want immediate access to Broadway and Times Square. The Peninsula New York is a classic five-star Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with about 219 rooms, a full-service spa and an indoor pool—read this if you’re weighing Midtown luxury against a more practical, theater-focused stay.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for theatergoers and families who want a convenient, walkable base steps from Times Square and Broadway.

Best for travelers seeking classic Manhattan five-star luxury, a spa and indoor pool near MoMA and 5th Avenue shopping.
When The Gallivant Times Square wins: Choose The Gallivant if you want to be in the heart of the Theater District, need family-friendly room configurations (bunks/family rooms and many room types), want more rooms for groups or events, or prefer a more budget-conscious Midtown stay with practical on-site dining.
When The Peninsula New York wins: Choose The Peninsula if you prioritize a traditional five-star experience—smaller guestroom count, on-site full-service spa, a 24-hour health club and an indoor pool, plus a classic Fifth Avenue address for museum and shopping access.
Bottom line: Pick The Gallivant for proximity to Broadway, flexible room layouts and a family focus; pick The Peninsula for a polished luxury stay with spa and pool amenities in Midtown Manhattan.
| Category | The Gallivant Times Square | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, theater-district practical | Classic five-star Fifth Avenue luxury |
| Location | 234 West 48th St, steps from Times Square and Broadway | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th St, near MoMA and 5th Avenue shopping |
| Size (rooms) | Approximately 334 guestrooms | 219 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family-friendly with rooms for kids | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Indoor pool (1) |
| Restaurants & bars | An'Nam (Vietnamese/Japanese), Ding (Korean BBQ tabletop), lobby cocktail bar | Clement Restaurant (American) and 3 bars/lounges (listed) |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; fitness center on-site (24-hour gym) | Full-service spa, steam room/sauna, 24-hour health club |
| Meeting & event space | Four meeting/event rooms (Boardroom, Lobby, An'Nam, Ding); largest capacity ~80 | Five meeting rooms available |
| Known for | Immediate access to Broadway and Times Square; family room options and refreshed gym | Classic Fifth Avenue address, luxury service, spa and pool |
| Wi‑Fi & fees | Complimentary Wi‑Fi (up to 3 devices) + mandatory facility fee ($40 plus tax per night) | Complimentary wired & wireless internet listed; additional fees for some services (breakfast, parking, etc.) |
The Gallivant sits in the Theater District on West 48th Street, an easy walk to Times Square and many Broadway theaters.
Ideal if your priority is Broadway, Times Square and quick subway links.
The Peninsula is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, close to museums and upscale shopping.
Better if you want Fifth Avenue shopping and museum access within a polished Midtown setting.
The Gallivant offers many room types and family-friendly layouts across roughly 334 rooms.
Choose The Gallivant for varied room layouts and options for families or groups.
The Peninsula has about 219 guestrooms with traditional luxury room options.
Pick The Peninsula for a smaller inventory of classic luxury rooms and suites.
The Gallivant focuses on practical, theater-friendly dining and a social lobby bar.
Good for pre- or post-show meals and informal group dining.
The Peninsula lists a single main restaurant and several bars for a formal luxury dining experience.
Better for travelers who want full-service, restaurant-forward luxury dining and late-night room service.
The Gallivant does not have an on-site swimming pool; its signature guest amenity is a 24-hour fitness center.
Skip The Gallivant if a pool or on-site spa is a must-have.
The Peninsula provides wellness amenities including a full-service spa and an indoor pool.
Choose The Peninsula when on-site spa treatments and a pool matter to your stay.
Gallivant’s wellness offering centers on a refreshed, 24-hour gym; nightlife is the surrounding Theater District.
Best if you plan to use a gym and attend shows or nearby bars rather than rely on hotel nightlife.
The Peninsula combines a 24-hour health club with hotel bars and a quieter Fifth Avenue setting for evening cocktails.
Better for guests who want on-site spa and quieter, classic hotel bars rather than street-level theater energy.

The Gallivant — steps from Broadway and Times Square with immediate theater access.

The Peninsula — full-service spa, indoor pool and 24-hour health club.

The Gallivant — many room types including family rooms and multiple junior penthouse layouts.

The Peninsula — smaller luxury inventory and a Fifth Avenue address near MoMA and high-end shopping.
The Gallivant Times Square is in the Theater District and is a shorter walk to many Broadway theaters than The Peninsula.
The Peninsula New York has an indoor pool and a full-service spa; The Gallivant does not have an on-site pool or spa.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; The Gallivant highlights family-friendly options while The Peninsula is not adults-only.
The Gallivant lists multiple event spaces and larger flexible capacities (An'Nam room up to ~80); The Peninsula also offers meeting rooms but positions itself as a luxury hotel with smaller overall room count.
Explore how The Gallivant Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·